Photos: Nancy’s Home Cooking re-opening

Good news for breakfast in Columbus and for diner culture in general! After months of fund raising, rehab, donations, inspections, delays, and more, Nancy’s Home Cooking reopened Friday, February 19.

We pulled up at Nancy’s around 7 am that day, before the sun came up, and the neon “open” sign glowed warmly across the street.

Just seeing the welcome sign and all the “open” signs gave me a warm feeling.

Inside, a crowd of regulars picked up right where they left off. Cindy King, the former owner, was on hand, as well as members of her family, and her niece Sheila Hahn, who took over the operations and led the efforts to remodel and re-open the Clintonville landmark.

The interior looks pretty much the same. The folks from Lowe’s donated a new floor. The counters and booths look new, but they’re arranged the same way. The kitchen is in the same layout, but now sports a new range hood. Some of the original signs are still hanging, although the menu has been taken off the wall and is now on individual cards on the tables. And everything’s got a fresh coat of paint. If cleanliness every kept you away from Nancy’s before, there’s no excuse now!

At the risk of sounding over-sentimental, especially for a place I haven’t visited nearly as often as many people, I found still this to be a really special occasion. You could see it in the faces of Cindy and Sheila and the small army of employees, all wearing black T-shirts with Nancy’s famous line “Eat it and beat it” on the back. (Cindy’s shirt said “Founder.”) You could see it in the faces of all the regulars who were eating their favorite breakfasts for the first time since June 2009. Every few minutes the door would open, and someone new would enter, to be greeted like Norm on Cheers. I can’t imagine what it must have felt like, if you were someone who ate at Nancy’s regularly for years, to actually be stepping through those doors again and see the familiar faces and smell those familiar smells. How often do you hear these days about small businesses that actually return after closing? I think it’s a testament to the power of the local and of the way food brings people together. It’s amazing how the community reacted to the closing, forming Facebook groups, holding fundraisers at local restaurants, and making donations from around the world. All to save this tiny hole-in-the-wall restaurant that holds such memories for each of them.

The opening has drawn a fair amount of press. Columbus Underground had an excellent interview with Sheila, and the Dispatch ran an article as well. A crew from Fox 28 did some live segments while we were there, too.

I ordered the same meal I had when I visited last May: 2 eggs, bacon, potatoes, and toast. It looked much the same as it did back in May.

And tasted just as delicious! Now I’ll actually have to get around to trying their famous garbage omelets and chicken and noodles.

Spread The Word...Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on Twitter0Pin on Pinterest1Share on StumbleUpon0Buffer this page


  1. says

    I'm totally bummed Nick. I was looking forward to this more than Spring. My daughter ordered 3 small pancakes (emphasis on small was made by me to the server) and bacon. 3 Gargantuan quickbread loaves arrived. Not delicate, mushy in the middle, overcooked on the outside. Horrible by any standard. Strike 1. I ordered what I get everywhere: eggs over-easy, hashbrowns, toast; it is what defines the skill of the griddle cook. I believe at some point in the life of these sad, red potatoes, they were hashbrowns and, at some point, cooked on a griddle, the color and appearance looked promising. But, seeing them pulled from a slowcooker was telling. The mushy mess was soon laying in front of me. If they are going to prep these ahead and stage them for serving like that, they should called 'em what they are, steamed/mashed potatoes. If I ever return, it might be for the chicken and noodles later in the day.

  2. says

    Oh, that's too bad, Dave! I've kinda wondered if they have any kinks to work out – maybe a new cook or something like that. Hopefully it'll improve!

  3. says

    We went this last Thursday and had a similar experience…The home fries were not crispy at all – more mushy. The eggs were good though. It's hard to find a proper sunny side up.The biggest disappointment was the sausage gravy. It smelled of chicken base and tasted like it too. Despite the fact we were assured it was the same recipe as before – I can assure you it was not. The hubby was so disappointed that he had me make some homemade S&G and B for dinner.I am going to give them about three months before I go back. As I said when Nancy's closed – it will never be the same. It can't be. That's just the way things are.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *